Jamaal Charles vs. Darren McFadden?

I'm a huge Jamaal Charles fan but TBH it's McFadden. Charles was a backup and IMO if he got as many carries as McFadden he wouldn't have gotten his 6 YPC. Plus McFadden is also pretty fast and he's tough. He's like a miny AP. Also look at another fast back, Reggie Bush, not really good as a starter. Charles and Bush are both playmakers though.